
UPSC ESSAY UPSC ETHICS MPPSC UPPSC BPSC RAS UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC CAPF
June 2, 2025 at 02:11 PM
🔆 Key Takeaways:
• Digital Platform Degradation (Enshittification):
◦ As digital platforms mature, user experience worsens—a phenomenon termed “enshittification” by journalist Cory Doctorow.
â—¦ Platforms initially prioritize users, then business clients, and eventually prioritize self-interest and profits.
• User Exploitation and Monetisation:
â—¦ Companies like Amazon, Spotify, and YouTube increasingly restrict user benefits (e.g., ads, reduced discounts, paid subscriptions).
◦ Escalating imposition of non-negotiable “platform fees” and “handling charges” represents a monetisation strategy post-dominance.
• Systemic Issues in Digital Ecosystems:
◦ Enshittification reflects systemic issues beyond just rising fees—such as device-based price discrimination and lack of transparency.
â—¦ Example: Differential pricing based on device type (iPhone vs. Android) without user consent or recourse.
• Dark Patterns and Manipulative UI:
â—¦ Platforms are increasingly using dark patterns to manipulate user behavior:
â–Ş False urgency (limited-time offers)
â–Ş Basket sneaking (adding items without consent)
â–Ş Drip pricing (hidden charges at checkout)
â–Ş Nagging (constant prompts)
â–Ş Subscription traps (making cancellations difficult)
â—¦ These practices mislead users and reduce informed choice.
• Legal and Regulatory Framework in India:
â—¦ Various laws and regulations aim to protect consumers:
▪ Consumer Protection Act, 2019 – Identifies unfair practices.
▪ E-Commerce Rules, 2020 – Enhances pricing transparency and prohibits unfair trade practices.
▪ Information Technology Rules, 2021 – Mandates redressal systems.
▪ Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 – Ensures user consent and privacy.
▪ Competition Act, 2002 – Regulates anti-competitive practices.
• Need for Stronger Regulatory Mechanisms:
◦ India’s digital framework needs to evolve to counter subtle, deceptive practices.
◦ Global models (e.g., EU’s Digital Markets Act) offer templates for stricter compliance and user protection, including:
â–Ş Banning self-preferencing,
â–Ş Ensuring interoperability,
â–Ş Mandatory UX audits,
▪ Defining “dark patterns.”
🙏
1