UPSC ETHICS UPSC UPSC™ UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC Upsc Upsc UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC™
January 26, 2025 at 02:19 PM
🔆 Ethical Perspective on Electronic Monitoring of Prisoners
📍 Balancing Overcrowding and Rights
⚖️ Electronic monitoring must balance reducing prison overcrowding with protecting privacy and dignity.
📍 Key Ethical Concerns
✅ Privacy Risks:
📱 Tracking devices may violate fundamental rights under Article 21, impacting privacy and bodily autonomy.
✅ Stigmatization:
🎯 Public knowledge of monitoring could lead to social stigma and loss of dignity for individuals.
✅ Proportionality:
⚡️ Use only in severe cases; applying it to minor offenders may be excessive and unfair.
✅ Voluntary Consent:
🤝 Respect informed consent to uphold individual autonomy.
📍 Utilitarian Perspective
🌟 Can reduce overcrowding and improve rehabilitation, but ethical implementation is key to avoiding harm.
📍 Recommendations
💡 Transparency: Clear rules on its use.
👁 Accountability: Oversight to prevent misuse.
🤲 Support: Combine monitoring with rehabilitation programs for holistic reform.
🔑 Conclusion
📢 Monitoring can be effective if implemented ethically, ensuring privacy, fairness, and human dignity.
#ethics