
UPSC ETHICS UPSC UPSC™ UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC Upsc Upsc UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC™
June 7, 2025 at 08:08 AM
🔆 Key Takeaways:
📍 Study on Police Torture in India:
- A comprehensive report by Common Cause and CSDS highlights disturbing patterns in police torture and custodial violence across India, based on interviews with 8,276 police personnel.
📍 Prevalence of Torture:
âś… 20% of police personnel believe using "tough methods" is *very important* for extracting information.
âś… 55% consider it *somewhat important*.
âś… 35% admitted that they have not talked about torture despite recognizing its use.
📍 Custodial Deaths and Discrepancies:
âś… Official statistics from NCRB and NHRC show a discrepancy in custodial deaths.
âś… A separate NGO report documented 111 deaths between 2018-22 with zero convictions, exposing the lack of accountability.
📍 Marginalized Communities Targeted:
âś… Victims of torture are predominantly from poor and marginalized backgrounds, including Dalits, Adivasis, Muslims, and those who cannot read/write.
📍 Use of “Third-Degree” Methods:
âś… 30% of police justified using third-degree methods for serious crimes.
âś… Kerala showed the highest compliance with procedural safeguards, while others reported inconsistent adherence.
📍 Lack of Medical Oversight:
âś… Arrested persons are often examined by doctors without forensic expertise.
✅ Many medical professionals act as “silent spectators,” failing to report signs of torture.
📍 Training and Reform Gaps:
âś… Only 17% of personnel received training in torture prevention.
âś… 71% were trained in human rights.
âś… Few supported evidence-based interrogation methods.
📍 Accountability and Legal Gaps:
âś… India has signed but not ratified the UN Convention Against Torture, making it non-binding.
âś… There is no standalone anti-torture law in India.
âś… The NHRC has been criticized for not defining or addressing "torture" adequately.
📍 Urgent Call for Legislation:
âś… Experts urge the enactment of a national law against torture.
âś… International examples (e.g., US, Iraq, China) reveal how unchecked power leads to severe abuses.
âś… Torture not only violates human rights but erodes public trust and rule of law.
📍 Conclusion:
✅ The report stresses the need for systemic reforms—clear laws, professional training, accountability, and political will—to end the culture of custodial torture in India.