UPSC ETHICS UPSC UPSC™ UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC Upsc Upsc UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC UPSC™
                                
                            
                            
                    
                                
                                
                                June 17, 2025 at 02:09 PM
                               
                            
                        
                            🔆 Key Takeaways:
📍 Study on Police Torture in India:
- A comprehensive report by Common Cause and CSDS highlights disturbing patterns in police torture and custodial violence across India, based on interviews with 8,276 police personnel.
📍 Prevalence of Torture:
✅ 20% of police personnel believe using "tough methods" is *very important* for extracting information.
✅ 55% consider it *somewhat important*.
✅ 35% admitted that they have not talked about torture despite recognizing its use.
📍 Custodial Deaths and Discrepancies:
✅ Official statistics from NCRB and NHRC show a discrepancy in custodial deaths.
✅ A separate NGO report documented 111 deaths between 2018-22 with zero convictions, exposing the lack of accountability.
📍 Marginalized Communities Targeted:
✅ Victims of torture are predominantly from poor and marginalized backgrounds, including Dalits, Adivasis, Muslims, and those who cannot read/write.
📍 Use of “Third-Degree” Methods:
✅ 30% of police justified using third-degree methods for serious crimes.
✅ Kerala showed the highest compliance with procedural safeguards, while others reported inconsistent adherence.
📍 Lack of Medical Oversight:
✅ Arrested persons are often examined by doctors without forensic expertise.
✅ Many medical professionals act as “silent spectators,” failing to report signs of torture.
📍 Training and Reform Gaps:
✅ Only 17% of personnel received training in torture prevention.
✅ 71% were trained in human rights.
✅ Few supported evidence-based interrogation methods.
📍 Accountability and Legal Gaps:
✅ India has signed but not ratified the UN Convention Against Torture, making it non-binding.
✅ There is no standalone anti-torture law in India.
✅ The NHRC has been criticized for not defining or addressing "torture" adequately.
📍 Urgent Call for Legislation:
✅ Experts urge the enactment of a national law against torture.
✅ International examples (e.g., US, Iraq, China) reveal how unchecked power leads to severe abuses.
✅ Torture not only violates human rights but erodes public trust and rule of law.
📍 Conclusion:
✅ The report stresses the need for systemic reforms—clear laws, professional training, accountability, and political will—to end the culture of custodial torture in India.